legalguruindia.com

Category: Blog Posts

[caption id="attachment_2710" align="alignnone" width="300"]TMWala Blog Posts Learn more about business registration, trademark registration, compliance and get updated with valuable business insights with TMWala Blog Posts.[/caption]

  • Ethical Considerations in Trademark Law: Why Playing Fair Matters

    Introduction

    In this age of competition, the name, logo, and identity of a brand are everything. Brands are recognized by their names and logos, so that is part of the reason people trust them. But what if somebody unjustly replicates a well-known brand’s emblem or title?

    This is where the ethical aspects of trademark law come in.There’s more to trademark law — registering logos or slogans — than just trademark law; it’s also about doing the right thing.

    Being ethical means that you play fair, that you respect other people’s work, and that you do not mislead customers.

    Let’s break this down to understand what it means in layman’s terms.

    What is a Trademark?

    A trademark can be a sign, symbol, word, or logo that helps people identify your business or product.

    For example Nike Swoosh, the McDonald’s golden arches or the Apple logo have become so synonymous with the companies that you can tell immediately who owns them.

    Trademarks provide confidence to consumers that they know what they are purchasing.

    This is why it’s so important that trademarks are used fairly and ethically.

    What Are Ethical Considerations in Trademark Law?

    Ethics in trademark law is about ensuring that:

    • You don’t replicate someone else’s brand.
    • You can make a ton of products under one logo or product line without confusing the customer into thinking they are all alike.
    • You are sensitive towards cultural and religious sentiments.
    • You don’t use trademarks in a way that damages the business or reputation of others.

    It’s about being honest and fair with your making and using your brand.

    Why Are Ethics Important in Trademark Law?

    The ethics in trademark law matter because:

    1. Protects Honest Businesses: If anyone was allowed to copy brands freely, this would harm original creators. Ethics safeguard people who work tirelessly to create their brands.
    2. Prevents Customer Confusion: Consider if you bought a sneaker designed to look like a Nike shoe, and when you bought it realized it was not the real thing — you would feel ripped off. We have ethics that guard against that kind of confusion.
    3. Encourages Creativity: Ethics, on the other hand encourage businesses to forge their own unique identities rather than imitating.
    4. Respects Society and Culture: Trademarks cannot offend public sentiments or tarnish religious symbols.
    5. Builds Long-Term Trust: In fact, ethical branding creates cult-like consumers who will trust you for years to come.

    Best Practices and Alternatives: A Case for Ethics

    Let’s understand this with simple examples:

    Ethical Practice

    • Creating a Unique Logo: Rather than copying, you come up with yourown new logo.
    • Choosing An Original Brand Name: You do not use names that are similar to known brand names.
    • Respecting National Symbols: You are not disrespecting a national flag or a religious symbol in your brand.

    Unethical Practice

    • Copying a Famous Logo: Creating a logo that was close to Nike’s Swoosh and deceiving customers.
    • Using Confusing Brand Names: We’re talking about Naming your company ”Adibas” to get people to think its Adidas.
    • Disrespecting religious Values: Using sacred images or holy slogans just to gather attention without understanding their meaning.

    Ethical Guidelines under Indian Trademark Law

    There are also some ethical rules enshrined within the Trade Marks Act, 1999 in Indian law:

    • The examiners also accept that you cannot register a trademark that offends religious sentiments.
    • You cannot register anything that is immoral or against public order.
    • You cannot trademark something too alike an existing brand.

    It safeguards that trademarks are not misleading, fair, and honest.

    How Young Entrepreneurs Can Be Ethical

    If you are a young entrepreneur launching a brand, this is what you can do to remain ethical:

    • Research Before You Create: Ensure your logo or name isn’t too similar to another person’s.
    • Respect Culture and Religion: Be sensitive in how you use names, images or slogans.
    • Be Original: All of your idea’s have more impact than ones you have taken from someone else.
    • Register Your Trademark: Legally protect your creativity so that no one else can abuse it.

    It is good for all of us, and ultimately, it is good for your brand success too!

    Ethics and Global Trademark Practices

    There is a lot of emphasis on ethical trademark practices even at the international level (WIPO – World Intellectual Property Organization):

    • Equal fairness is expected from global companies.
    • Trademarks that deceive, confuse or are harmful to public interests are prohibited.
    • No matter, whether you’re a small business owner in India or a big startup dreaming international, ethics matter everywhere.

    Conclusion: Ethics = Stronger Brands

    It is not about who files first

    It’s about who plays fair.

    Ethical considerations ensure that:

    • Good businesses thrive.
    • Customers are happy.
    • Innovation continues.

    Young innovation entrepreneurs need to remember that success without values is temporary.

    But success in the realm of ethics, engenders trust, loyalty and respect — the cornerstones of any great brand.

    Thus, create your brand with creativity, guard it with trademark law and reinforce it with ethics.

    Because, after all, playing fair is the smartest business strategy!

    “Create Uniquely. Protect Legally. Grow Ethically.”

    Author Details: Aditya Krishna Gupta, 3rd year, BA LL.B. ,Jiwaji University, Gwalior 

    Reference Links:

    https://www.wipo.int/trademarks/en

    https://www.businesstoday.in/latest/corporate/story/patanjali-trademark-disputes-brand-name-legal-row-255678-2021-06-15

  • UNDERSTANDING THE GST ADJUDICATION PROCESS: FROM DETECTION TO APPEAL

    INTRODUCTION

    The Goods and Services Tax (GST), which took effect in India from 2017, has swept away huge structural changes to the landscape of indirect taxation. GST adjudication lifecycle consists of various stages, starting from detection of anomalies to investigations, to the issuance of SCNs adjudication and appeals. There are legal processes that manage each stage to guarantee fairness, transparency, and accountability.

    This article covers the entire process under the umbrella of the GST law, commencing from the stage at which a case generally originates, be it system-based red flags, departmental audits, or any intelligence input, and explains how the proceedings pass through each stage before its final conclusion.

    DETECTION AND INITIATION OF PROCEEDINGS

    Proceedings under the Goods and Services Tax (GST) regime are an important part of curtailing tax evasion and ensuring compliance with legal regulations. It starts by noticing discrepancies or patterns that might indicate violations. The main concerns that lead to such proceedings include:

    a. Data Analytics and Systematic Flags

    GST Network (GSTN) uses advanced data analytics to process and analyze the humongous data collected from the taxpayers. Discrepancies found in this analysis can spark additional scrutiny. Common red flags include:

    • Mismatch in GSTR-1 & GSTR-3B: If the details of outward supplies shown in GSTR-1 do not match with the summary return in GSTR-3B, it might be possible that the sales or tax liability is suppressed.
    • Differences in Input Tax Credit (ITC): If the ITC claimed in GSTR-3B compared to that auto-populated in GSTR-2B shows a significant difference, it may indicate some ineligible or excess claims.
    • Delay or non-filing of returns: If there is a consistent delay or failure to file statutory returns, it can trigger investigations.
    • Unusual transaction patterns: Sudden surges of turnover, frequent return amendments, and transactions with high-risk taxpayers can all raise suspicion.

    b. Audit Findings

    Taxes authorities are empowered to do a registered person audit under Section 65 of CGST Act. These audits are conducted to ascertain the correctness of the turnover declared, tax paid, refund claimed, and ITC availed. The results of such audits, especially where there are major discrepancies or instances of non-compliance, may result in the commencement of proceedings.

    c. Scrutiny of Returns

    Section 61 of the CGST Act empowers tax officers to examine returns and other particulars for the purpose of ensuring their correctness. If exist discrepancies in scrutiny else wise, the taxpayer may be called for explanation. Failure to respond satisfactorily or correct the discrepancies will result in further action.

    d. Intelligence Inputs

    It can also be based on information received from other government departments, informants or internal intelligence units. These inputs of intelligence are collected and acted upon by the Directorate General of GST Intelligence (DGGI) which does the lion’s share of work in this regard.

    e. Risk-Based Selection

    The GST framework has provisions that have been termed as risk parameters, whereby tax payers who are likely to be at an increased risk of fraud are identified. Things like the nature of business, transaction volumes, and compliance history are taken into account. Taxpayers identified through this risk-based methodology may be audited or investigated.

    f. Voluntary Disclosures

    Taxpayers themselves can also discover errors or omissions in their returns and voluntarily inform the tax authorities of such omissions. The scope of this discretion is subject to judicial review; disclosures made under a commitment may mitigate penalties, but also further open the books for scrutiny to make sure the information is complete and accurate.

    PRELIMINARY INQUIRY AND INVESTIGATION

    Whenever there is a chance of non-compliance, a preliminary inquiry by the GST authorities is conducted to confirm the facts of the decrease. This is a critical phase to see whether formal proceedings would be appropriate.” These are the main components of this phase:

    a. Issuance of Summons [Section 70 of CGST Act]

    Section 70 of the CGST Act grants the proper officer the authority to summon any person whose attendance is considered necessary to provide evidence or produce documents relevant to an inquiry. The summons process is similar to that in civil court proceedings and ensures that the inquiry maintains judicial propriety.

    b. Inspection, Search and Seizure (Sec. 67 of the CGST Act)

    Section 67 gives powers to a proper officer not below the rank of Joint Commissioner to authorize inspections, searches, and seizure operations if there is reason to believe that:

    • A taxable person has ‘hidden’ transactions or stock, claimed too much input tax credit, or broken terms to avoid tax.
    • Any goods liable for confiscation or relevant documents secreted in any place.

    In this case, any other officer may be authorized in writing by the officer to search and seize such goods, documents, or books as may be useful for the proceedings under the Act.

    c. Statement recording and Collection of Evidence

    Statements of the taxpayer and other persons concerned are recorded to gather evidences during the investigation. These statements are taken on oath and can be used in subsequent proceedings and are also used to be read by judges in other cases to expedite them. Gathering evidence can include scrutinizing financial records, invoices, or any documentation relevant to the case.

    d. Retention and Return of Seized Items

    According to Section 67(3) of CGST Act, any documents/books/things being seized shall be returned within a period of 30 days from the date of issuance of notice unless the documents are required to be kept for further investigation. The proper officer shall record in writing the reasons for retaining the seized items beyond this period.

    e. Stipulatory Protections and Pro Novate Review

    Taxpayers can be represented by a tax professional in the course of the investigation process. Moreover, natural justice is not only the wisest policy, but the statutory law that an opportunity to be heard, and to adduce evidence in defence, must be afforded to the taxpayer. These powers can only be exercised with a proper judicial oversight.

    ISSUANCE OF SHOW CAUSE NOTICE (SCN)

    a. Legal Framework: Section 73 and 74 of the CGST Act

    The CGST Act specifies the circumstances when an SCN may be issued:

    • Section 73: This section applies to cases involving non-payment, short-payment, erroneous refunds or incorrect availing or utilization of input tax credit (ITC), but where there is no element of fraud or willful misstatement.
    • Section 74: It refers to similar cases but involving figurative fraud, intentional mis-statements, or concealment of facts with the intention to avoid tax.

    Importantly, for periods related to FY 2024-25 and beyond, a new Section 74A has been introduced, combining provisions related to both fraudulent and non-fraudulent cases.

    b. Time Limits for Issuance

    SCNs need to be issued in a timely manner to ensure that principles of natural justice are upheld:

    • Section 73: SCN should be issued at least 3 months before the expiry of 3 years from the due date of the annual return for the relevant FY.
    • Section 74: An SCN shall be issued at least six months before the completion of five years from the due date for filing the annual return for the concerned financial year.

    Ex: the due date for filing the annual return for Financial Year 2020-21 was 31st December 2021. Thus, under Section 73, the SCN was to be issued within 30th September 2024 and under Section 74 by 30th June 2026.

    c. Understanding Voluntary Payment and its Consequences

    Taxpayers may also make voluntary payments to help reduce the penalty:​

    Before SCN: Voluntary payment through Form DRC-03 helps avoid a Penalty.

    After SCN: If within 30 days, payment is made, then the reduced penalty is applicable.

    • Section 73: 10% of the tax due or ₹10,000, whichever is higher.
    • Section 74: 25% of the tax amount

    REPLY, REPRESENTATION, AND PERSONAL HEARING

    The taxpayer can respond to the Show Cause Notice (SCN) once it is issued. This step makes sure that before anything is finalized, that that taxpayer has the opportunity to have their case presented. The rules governing this process are set out below.

    a. Reply to the SCN

    On receipt of SCN, the taxpayer must file a written reply to the relevant adjudicating authority typically within thirty days of receipt as per Section 73 and 74 of the CGST Act.

    • A response to SCN must also be filed together with supporting documents or records denying the allegations made therein.
    • The response is filed online in Form GST DRC-06 on the GST portal.

    b. Right to Personal Hearing

    The taxpayer is granted the right to a personal hearing under Section 75(4) of the CGST Act. Where the taxpayer makes a request, the adjudicating authority ought to give an opportunity for hearing.

    • It should be scheduled after the taxpayer receives the SCN and the reply filed by the taxpayer.
    • A taxpayer can represent himself or herself or be represented by an authorized representative.

    c. Non-compliance with reply or Hearing

    If a taxpayer does not respond or appear for a hearing, the adjudicating authority, at this stage, may take up the case ex parte, based on the available records.

    ADJUDICATION AND PASSING OF ORDER

    After receiving the reply to the SCN along with concluding of personal hearing (if any), the adjudicating authority adjudicates the matter based on available records, submissions and provision of the law.

    a. Relevant Provisions

    Provisions regarding the issuance of adjudication orders post the SCN process are provided in section 73(9) and section 74(9) of the CGST Act.

    The authority is also required to pass an order in writing by giving specific reasons setting out the amount of tax, interest and penalty, if any, payable.

    b. Time limit for passing order

    Section 73 (non-fraud cases):  Order to be passed within 3 years from the due date for filing annual return for the relevant year.

    Section 74 (fraud cases): Order to be passed within 5 years from the due date of annual return for the relevant year.

    c. Format of the Order

    The issuance of order is in Form GST DRC-07 that acts as a summary of demand.

    The order includes:

    • Tax, interest, and penalty affirmed
    • Grounds for decision
    • Reference to answer and hearing
    • Directions for payment

    d. Implication of Order

    If the taxpayer does not pay the sum within the time allowed, the order becomes the basis for recovery proceedings under Section 78.

    The taxpayer also obtains the right to appeal under Section 107 within three months from the date of such order.

    APPEALS AND FURTHER REMEDIES

    In such a situation, if a taxpayer wants to appeal against the adjudication order passed by the GST authorities, the GST law prescribes a mechanism thereof.

    a. First Appeal: Section 107 of CGST Act

    The aggrieved taxpayer can file an appeal against the adjudication order before the Appellate Authority as per Section 107.

    Limitation: The appeal should be filed within 3 months of communication of the order.

    Form: The appeal shall be presented in Form GST APL-01 and shall be accompanied by a copy of the order appealed against.

    b. Pre-Deposit Requirement

    As per Section 107(6), for the appeal to be admitted:

    • 100% of the admitted tax liability must be paid.
    • 10% of the disputed tax amount must be paid as a pre-deposit (subject to a maximum of ₹25 crore).

    c. Further Appeal to Appellate Tribunal (GSTAT)

    If unsatisfied with the decision of the Appellate Authority, an appeal can be filed before the Goods and Services Tax Appellate Tribunal (GSTAT) under Section 112.

    The Tribunal is the second level of appellate review but is not yet fully functional across all jurisdictions as of early 2025.Time Limit: Appeal must be filed within 3 months of receipt of the order from the Appellate Authority.

    d. Appeal to High Court and Supreme Court

    On substantial questions of law, further appeals lie to the High Court under Section 117, and subsequently to the Supreme Court under Section 118.

    e. Alternate Remedies

    In cases involving procedural violations or denial of natural justice, a taxpayer can also approach the High Court under Article 226 of the Constitution through a writ petition, though this is an exceptional remedy.

    CONCLUSION

    The GST regime provides a robust, time-bound, and procedurally fair framework for identification, investigation, and adjudication of such tax disputes. The entire process, from detecting discrepancies to issuing orders and appreciating appellate remedies, is the right balance between enforcement and protecting taxpayer rights. But successful implementation relies on timely compliance, adequate documentation and informed representation on the taxpayers’ part.

    Author Details: Ananya Pathak, 4th year, B.Com LL.B., Jiwaji University

  • HOW TO SAVE TAX IN A PRIVATE LIMITED COMPANY

    ABSTRACT

    This article discusses different legal and strategic about how to save tax in a Private Limited Company in India. The article starts with discussing major tax exemptions for companies in India, Section 80-IAC, and Section 80JJAA. It then highlights the necessity of compliance in the form of tax audits for a private limited company, especially under Section 44AB of the Income Tax Act. The article also discusses requirements related to professional tax for a private limited company, applicable at the state level for both employers and employees.

    A major part is devoted to tax-saving techniques like claiming depreciation under the Income Tax Act, and utilizing business-related expenses like director remunerations, sitting fees, rent, preliminary expenses, and family member remunerations. It also emphasizes deductions through different operational expenses like entertainment, meetings, and vehicle costs. Through these steps, Private Limited Companies can legally reduce tax liability while remaining in accordance with Indian tax regulations.

    INTRODUCTION

    A Private limited company is formed lawfully with limited liability or legal protection for its shareholders but that places restrictions on its ownership. Amongst many obligations, paying tax is one of the main obligations of a company.

    HOW TO SAVE TAX IN A PRIVATE LIMITED COMPANY:

    1. UNDER TAX EXEMPTION FOR COMPANIES IN INDIA

    One of the most effective ways to save tax is by availing various tax exemptions for companies in India. The government offers several benefits to startups and new private limited companies, such as:

    • Startup India scheme: eligible startups can get a tax holiday for consecutive years under section 80 IAC.
    • Income tax rebate under section 10 (38): long-term capital gains on shares and securities can be exempt under certain conditions.
    • Deduction under section 80 JJAA: for companies that hire new employees.

    2. MAINTAIN COMPLIANCE THROUGH TAX AUDIT FOR A PRIVATE LIMITED COMPANY

    Every private limited company must conduct a tax audit for a private limited company under section 44AB of the Income Tax Act if:

    • Annual turnover exceeds Rs. 1 crore for business (or Rs. 50 lakhs for professionals)
    • Companies are opting for presumptive taxation under section 44AD/44ADA and not declaring profits as per the norms.

    3. PAY ATTENTION TO PROFESSIONAL TAX FOR A PRIVATE LIMITED COMPANY

    Another mandatory tax is the professional tax for a private limited company. Levied by respective state governments.

    • Deducted form the employer and the employee depending on the state’s laws.
    • Must be paid by both the employer and the employee depending on the state’s laws.

    4. USE DEPRECIATION UNDER THE INCOME TAX ACT

    Claiming depreciation under Income Tax Act is one of the most effective ways to reduce taxable income. Section 32 allows companies to depreciate assets such as:

    • Machinery and equipment
    • Office furniture
    • Computers and vehicles

    5. ADDITIONAL TIPS ON HOW TO SAVE TAX IN A PRIVATE LIMITED COMPANY IN INDIA

    Salary to Director:

    • The simplest way to save taxes is to pay their directors.
    • Since you founded the business, you have the option to divide the profits as a salary as opposed to a dividend.
    • Salary is the private limited company’s authorized expense.

    Sitting fees to the director:

    • A director may receive a sitting fee from the company for attending board or committee meetings; the amount may be determined by the board of directors and cannot exceed one lakh each board or committee meeting.
    • That is exempt in the hands of an individual under the specified limit and can be claimed as “Expenditure” in the hands of a business.

    Depreciation on assets:

    • When an asset is purchased, it is shown on the company’s balance sheet as a capital asset.
    • In this manner, the purchase item will show up on the asset side of the balance sheet rather than the profit and loss statement.

    Preliminary expenses:

    • The founder of a private limited company bears the costs associated with the firm’s creation, which are known as preliminary expenses.
    • A number of costs are incurred both before and after the incorporation of a private limited company.
    • These costs are professional fees paid for the creation of the AOA and MOA. Document printing expenses, ROC fees, stamp duty, etc.

    Rent expenses:

    • All you need to do is create a rent agreement in the owner’s name, begin transferring the rent, and record the rent expense in the company’s books
    • if the location listed as the registered address of the business is in the name of the director or any of the director’s relatives.

    Salary expenditure of a family member:

    • When family members work for the company, begin recording their pay as an expense in the accounts of the business.
    • In this manner, you can bring your earnings home once more.

    Entertainment expenses:

    • Then there is the most exciting business expense.
    • You should periodically celebrate your company’s accomplishments.
    • By recording the expense in your books of accounts, you can save 30% on taxes.

    Meeting expenses:

    • Expenses for attending a sporting event, a theatre performance, or a client meal are deductible.
    • Additionally, for professional purposes when you interact with others, attend numerous meetings, and travel to other locations.
    • You can lower your taxes by properly recording and keeping track of all such expenses.

    Director’s vehicle expenses:

    • A director’s car is typically used for business travel and meetings.
    • Fuel consumption and vehicle maintenance can be recorded as business expenses in the company’s records since they are specifically related to the business.

    CONCLUSION

    How to save tax in a private limited company in India is the most crucial question that has to be dealt with as it effective tax planning is essential for the financial health and sustainability of a Private Limited Company in India. By taking advantage of government-provided tax exemptions for companies in India, maintaining proper compliance, tax audit for private limited company and strategically recording legitimate business expenses, companies can significantly reduce their tax burden while staying within legal boundaries.

    From utilizing startup tax benefits and claiming depreciation under the Income Tax Act, including director salaries and everyday business expenses, there are numerous opportunities to optimize tax outflows. Apart from these doing professional tax for a private company is also very important.

    However, it’s important that all such practices are well documented and compliant with prevailing laws to avoid penalties. Seeking professional advice and maintaining transparent financial records can ensure both savings and long-term business stability. Ultimately, smart tax management not only improves profitability but also fosters growth and reinvestment in the company.

  • Section 8 Company Closure and Workforce Management

    Introduction

    A Section 8 Company is a company which is established for charitable purposes. Section 8 Company is basically a Non-Profit Organisation which is registered under the provisions of the Companies Act. Establishing and running a Section 8 Company is a tedious task requiring various workforce management compliances like notice period rules for employee, employee termination policy in India etc. Apart from this, Section 8 Companies are regularly encountered with several other operational challenges including lack of funding, absence of resources etc., due to which, Section 8 Companies may find it difficult to stay afloat and seek closure.

    Hence, this article provides a comprehensive overview of the legality and procedure involved in Section 8 Company closure and effective workforce management.

    Legal and Compliance Requirements for Employee Termination in a Section 8 Company

    The employee termination policy in India during the closure of a Section 8 company must be managed with strict adherence to labor laws and statutory obligations. This ensures that employees are treated fairly, their rights are protected, and the organization fulfills its legal responsibilities. Adhering to employment laws, along with transparent communication with employees, is essential to avoid disputes during the process.

    Adherence to Employment and Labor Laws

    • Labor Laws: Comply with relevant labor laws such as the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, and the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972, which outline the procedures for employee termination policy in India.
    • Employment Law Compliance: Ensure that all statutory dues, including unpaid salaries, gratuity, provident fund (EPF), and Employee State Insurance (ESI) contributions, are settled before termination.
    • Statutory Compliance: Verify that the employee termination policy in india aligns with the company’s employment contracts, HR policies, and applicable labor laws.
    • Audit for Compliance: Conduct a thorough audit to ensure that all legal obligations are fulfilled.
    • Government Regulations: File the necessary reports with labor authorities or government departments as required by law.

    Notice period rules for an employee

    1. Notice Period:
      Provide employees with the required notice period as per their employment contracts or labor laws. If immediate termination is necessary, offer compensation in lieu of the notice period as per notice period rules for employee.

    2. Termination Notice:
      As per the termination policy in India the company has to issue formal termination letters detailing the reasons for termination, the effective date, and any compensation offered. Include information about severance pay and other entitlements to ensure clarity.

    3. Employee Communication:
      Maintain transparency by clearly explaining the reasons for termination and the organization’s closure. Offer employees an opportunity to discuss their concerns and provide a platform for addressing grievances.

    4. Formal Notification:
      Communicate the termination decision in writing to ensure there is a formal record of the process. Notify relevant stakeholders, including labor unions or employee representatives, if applicable.

    5. Company Closure Procedure Announcement:
       Ensure that employees are informed about the company closure procedure in a timely and empathetic manner. Share details about the steps being taken to comply with legal requirements and support employees during the transition.

    Understanding Company Closure procedure of Section 8 company

    Company closure procedure of section 8 company is a highly technical process that begins with:

    1. Calling a general meeting is the first stage in closing a Section 8 company. To particularly address the issue of winding up the section 8 company, the board of directors of the company must take the initiative to summon a special general meeting (SGM) of the members.
    2. The court or the company’s members may designate a suitable person to act as a liquidator, charged with managing the winding up procedure.
    3. Call an EGM and adopt a special resolution (SR) if shareholders approve of the decision. The closure process can then start.Within 30 days of passing the SR in the EGM, submit MGT-14 together with all applicable documents, DSC, and costs
    4. The regional director (RD) must then receive the completed INC-18, the required documentation, and the conversion fees.

    Documents Required for the section 8  company closure process

    Following is the required list of documents:

    • A copy of the meeting notice, which includes the explanatory statement, the Association memorandum, the articles of incorporation, and a certified copy of the special resolution
    • The board resolution or resolutions that approved the conversion in a certified copy
    • A certified true copy of the notification calling the general meeting, the relevant explanatory statement attached to it, and the special resolution passed for approval of any other type of conversion
    • A CS, CWA, or CA’s (in practice) certificate attesting to compliance with the Act’s and the rules’ requirements. A statement, properly attested by the auditor, showing the company’s assets and liabilities as of a given date within thirty days of that date
    • A copy of an asset market value report from a registered value
    • For each of the two fiscal years that immediately preceded the application date, or for that year if the company had only been in operation for one fiscal year, financial statements, board of directors reports, annual returns, and audit reports
    • Each of the creditors, if any, must provide a letter of authorization.
    • All of the Regional Director’s requirements were stated in a statement from the directors.

    Conclusion

    The closure of a section 8 company in India involves a structural legal process that ensures transparency and compliance with regulatory frameworks. understanding the procedural steps and documentation required for company closure is crucial, especially in the not for profit sector. Equally important is adherence to employee termination policy in India, which must align with Indian labor laws to ensure fair treatment of staff during winding up , proper implementation of notice period rules not only safeguards employee rights but also helps maintain the company’s integrity  during its final stages. By carefully following the legal procedures and obligations, a section 8 company can conclude its operations responsibly and lawfully

  • GST RATES ON GOLD

    Abstract:

    In this article, we will discuss the impact of Goods and Services Tax (GST) on gold in India, GST rates on gold, GST on old gold exchanges, GST on sovereign gold bonds, etc. As gold holds a significant place in Indian culture and investment portfolios, it becomes crucial to know how GST affects its pricing and taxation. The article talks about the tax implications on gold under GST, including how VAT is no more applicable, benefits on sovereign gold bonds, and GST calculation on gold purchases along with making charges. We will also highlight GST implications in the case of second-hand gold and the comparison with previous VAT principles.

    The article also examines GST-wielding the overall consequences on gold Prices in Indian Market. This guide is for consumers, traders and tax professionals who want to understand how gold in its different forms are taxed under GST. Understand what role compliance requirements, rate slabs & exemptions play in the gold market today.

    Introduction;

    Gold has always played a vital role in Indian culture and economy. In 2017, taxation for gold came under a paradigm shift with the implementation of the Goods and Service Tax (GST). This article explains GST rates on gold jewellery, impact of GST on gold prices, and how to calculate GST for gold purchases.

    Pre- GST tax structure on Gold

    Prior to the implementation of the GST regime in India, gold was being taxed under various heads such as VAT on gold, central excise and customs duty. The total tax rate was different by state, making prices inconsistent and compliance challenging, the report said.

    Buyers were charged approximately 1% VAT on goldbesides 1% excise duty (in some cases), 10% customs duty on imports. Some states also imposed octroi or entry tax, further burdening business.

    The pre-GST structure, therefore, needed reform,  paving the way for a unified system that would simplify taxation while increasing some level of visibility for both buyers and jewellers.

    GST Regime in India and How it Impacted Gold

    Since implementation of GST regime in India in July 2017, taxation of gold has been rationalised and placed under one umbrella. This replaced the previous multilevel tax system with a more simple and uniform approach across states.

    As per GST, gold attracts 3% GST on the value, and making charges on the gold jewellery are taxed at 5% separately. This two-rate system applies equally to new and customised gold ornaments.

    GST offered opportunities and responsibilities for jewellers. The system did recognise input tax credit on business purchases, but once the GST registration crossed a certain threshold (which again depended on turnover), meant constant filing, proper invoicing, proper accounting, etc.

    On the whole, GST contributed to formalisation of the sector, reduced tax evasion, and enhanced compliance. It also clarified long-held misconceptions about gold products, including prices and taxation, among consumers.

    GST Rates on Gold Jewellery

    Gold jewellery is taxed at a 3% standard rate on standard gold under the GST system. The making charges, which form of the labour or service component, would be separately chargeable at 5% GST if charged as separate item.

    This implies that when a customer purchases gold ornaments, the final bill is 3% GST on the value of gold and 5% on making charges, whether the jewels are ready-made or custom-designed. When charges of performance are included in the price, then the total value is taxed.

    While the tax rate did go up a little compared to the pre-GST era (which had only a 1% VAT on gold), the systematic and transparent manner under which GST works has made it easier for both buyers and sellers to know how much tax is being levied on gold jewellery.

    GST on old gold exchange

    The value on which the GST is payable when a customer is exchanging old gold jewellery for new ornaments is only the value of the new jewellery and not on the old gold he is giving in exchange. The jeweller passes the old gold received as a purchase and no GST is applied on old gold.

    For instance, if you trade in your old bangles worth ₹30,000 for a necklace worth ₹70,000, GST is applied only on the net ₹40,000 difference (plus any making charges, if applicable). This makes GST on old gold exchange relatively customer-friendly and aids in the recycling of gold in the industry.

    However, Jewellers must document these transactions appropriately to comply.

    How to Calculate GST for Gold?

    The GST on gold is charged on two components — the value of the gold itself and the making charge. Under the GST regime in India, a 3% tax is applied to gold purchases and a 5% tax applies to making charges, which is classified as a service.

    To understand the calculation, here is a basic step by step example:

    Say you are purchasing a gold necklace:

    Gold worth (weight × rate): ₹50,000

    Making charges: ₹5,000

    At present, GST is being computed in such a way:

    GST @3% on gold: ₹50,000 × 3% = ₹1,500

    GST @5% on making charges: ₹5,000 × 5% = ₹250

    Total price payable = 50000 + 5000 + 1500 + 250 = ₹56,750

    So whenever you are purchasing gold jewellery, keep in mind that the GST rates on gold jewellery comprise of 3% on the value of gold and 5% on making charges. Such transparency in breaking down the cost demystifies the tax element and allows customers to compare prices among jewellers.

    For consumers, it’s wise to ask for an itemized invoice that reflects this breakup. Correct calculation and billing are very important for jewellers for smooth GST compliance and also to claim input credit.

    Impact of GST on Gold Prices and Market Behaviour

    • A change in the Gold prices and the buying patterns was evident after the implementation of the GST. Under current GST regime, while gold jewellery is taxed at 3%, making charges attract 5% GST tax, overall tax incidence for the gold jewellery sector has gone up compared to earlier regime when only 1% VAT and 1% excise were applicable.
    • This period saw a slight increase in the gold values, especially during the early transition. On the other hand, some of the price increase effect was offset by increased transparency and standard pricing that makes it simpler for consumers to comprehend the final price they would have to pay for the product.
    • The market-wise, the enforcement of GST prompted several jewellers to get into the formal sector, particularly due to input credit benefits and mandatory invoicing. It also cracked down on unaccounted cash transactions that were once common in the gold trade.
    • The market gradually adjusted with consumers being more educated about the tax component and jewellers more compliant. While GST had a temporary effect on gold prices, its introduction did play a long-term role in formalizing and streamlining the industry.

    Tax Benefit on Sovereign Gold Bond

    Being an attractive instrument with tax benefits as per the present taxation regime, Sovereign Gold Bonds (SGBs) are superior to physical gold in every aspect. Launched by the Reserve Bank of India on behalf of the government, SGBs are certificates in the gold, and investors do not have to worry about storage or purity.

    The primary benefit is taxation, no GST will be imposed on the purchase of SGBs, since they are considered financial assets, not physical goods. They are therefore attractive compared to buying gold jewellery, which attracts GST on gold jewellery and making charges.

    Also, the income from SGBs (2.5% per annum) is liable to tax and capital gains on redemption (after 8 years) is tax-free (for individuals) in full. Such features make SGBs particularly attractive for long-term investors looking out for safety as well as tax-efficiency.

    To sum up, the tax saving in sovereign gold bond makes it economical when compared to buying gold in the physical form, particularly in a GST market.

    Conclusion

    Under GST, the gold industry in India got much clarity and structure. The GST rates on gold jewellery did raise the overall tax slightly but made for a simpler system that increased compliance and created trust in consumers. Important facets such as GST on old gold exchange, transparent invoicing and tax benefit on Sovereign Gold Bond have transformed the method of buying and selling gold.

    Buyers and dealers are now more vigilant and responsible. Learn About GST on Gold: For consumers, knowledge of how G.S.T. is computed on gold will help them make informed buying choices. For jewellers, forgoing to adjust with the GST regime in India provides long-term credibility in a closely knitted regulatory space.

    GST continues to play a pivotal role in the move towards a more organised, transparent and investor-friendly gold ecosystem as the market walks down the learning curve.

    References:

    https://www.axismaxlife.com/blog/tax-savings/gst-on-gold

    https://cleartax.in/s/gst-impact-on-gold

  • INTELLECTUAL PROPERTIES: IN MY DREAM HOUSE

    It’s a story of a dream home (sapano ka ghar). Although this story or the seed of this dream started from my childhood. I have been raised in a family of eight people: my mom dad and 5 siblings. We all used to live in an apartment in Deeg, a small city near Agra. Moreover, we will dive in the knowledge of this topic intellectual properties in my dream house.

    In the apartment we all used to live only has two rooms, one kitchen and one bathroom. One room is mainly used as a hall for the purpose of welcoming guests into the house. That leaves us with only one room where our whole family used to live. One of my siblings was very small; he used to sleep with Mom and Dad, and the other four siblings used to live with me in the same room where we all used to play, fight, study and do everything.

    At that moment, it’s my dream and mission to build The House of My Dream. Now after these years of wait me and my best friend has finally found The Place in our dream neighbourhood that is two big plots side by side, makes it so much easier to visit each other whenever we want.

    Soon after looking into the property, we managed to buy the plots with all the legal paperwork done by my lawyer who is also my best friend with whom I have purchased the property.

    1. THE COPYRIGHT ACT, 1957:

    As we embarked on the journey of designing our dream home, one of the most exciting yet overwhelming tasks was the blueprint of the house and also the elevation design for that, we worked closely with our architect to develop a custom blueprint and elevation, designed entirely to our vision something that reflects our personal taste.

    This blueprint, which includes the floor plan, room layout, and along with the elevation, is a result of creative and technical planning. As such, it qualifies as an “artistic work” under Section 2(c) of the Copyright Act, 1957.

    According to Indian copyright law, the moment an original work like this is created the architect or client gains automatic copyright protection. So, any unauthorised use by someone else other than the original owner would amount to copyright infringement.

    2. THE TRADEMARK ACT, 1999:

    As part of our interior planning process, we visited several tile showrooms across the city. To our surprise, we were overwhelmed by the vast range of options available in tiles differing not just in colours and patterns, but also in shape and material. Each brand showcased something unique. While some tiles were known for their strength and durability, others, though visually appearing stronger and beautiful, were relatively fragile and less reliable in terms of long-term quality.

    After comparing various samples and considering both aesthetics and durability, we decided to go with tiles manufactured by the renowned brand ‘Kajaria’. Kajaria has built a strong reputation over the years for producing high-quality, long-lasting tiles, and their tagline “The quality speaks for itself” truly aligns with our experience.

    In the process, we also came across other reputed companies like Somany Ceramics and Johnson Tiles, each of them has established a strong brand identity. A common feature among these top brands is that their logos are printed on the reverse side of every tile, and also prominently displayed on the packaging. This branding serves as a mark of authenticity and trust.

    From an Intellectual Property Rights perspective, this is a clear example of protection under the Trademarks Act, 1999. The name, logo, tagline, and even specific branding elements used by these companies are all protected trademarks. These trademarks not only help distinguish one company’s products from another’s in a competitive market but also play a vital role in maintaining the goodwill and reputation the company has earned among consumers.

    Moreover, trademarks are essential in preventing duplicating and misuse of a well-established brand. If a local manufacturer attempts to falsely use the name or similar logo of Kajaria, for instance, it will amount to trademark infringement and the legal protections under the Trademarks Act would allow Kajaria to take action to protect its brand.

    Thus, our choice of tiles was not just based on looks or price, but also on the credibility that the brand carrieswith itself, assuring us that we are investing in a product that is trusted, original, and protected under Indian IPR laws.

    After finalizing the customized blueprint and elevation of our house protected under copyright and selecting high-quality, trademarked tiles from a trusted brand like Kajaria, we moved to another vital part of the home-building journey: choosing the right fans and lighting. In terms of durability for long-term use, energy efficiency to reduce electricity bills, and of course a design that elevates the aesthetic vibe of every room.

    We explored fans and lights from several companies, but our attention was drawn to Havells, a name known for its quality, innovation, and customer satisfaction. From ceiling fans to smart LED panel lights and decorative chandeliers, every product reflected the premium quality.

    The brand name “Havells”, along with its logo, taglines, and different branding style, is protected under the Trademarks Act, 1999. This Act ensure that no other company can use the Havells brand name or similar trademarks to mislead customers, So the company’s reputation and goodwill remain legally intact. And, the consumers like us can confidently choose products, knowing they are backed by a protected brand.

    In taps and showerheads, we specifically chose fittings from Jaquar®, a brand known not just for its appearance, but for durability, water-saving technology, and customer service. The brand name and logo printed on every product, packaging box, and even on the handles themselves, is not just a mark of identity, it is a registered trademark protected under the Trademarks Act, 1999. The Act ensures protection of the name, logo, and tagline of the brand. The brand’s reputation, consumer trust, and goodwill remain protected.

    3. THE DESIGNS ACT, 2000:

    Havells is also stood out for its design innovation like for instance the ceiling fans with wooden blade, LED lights in geometric patterns, & floral designs that blend beautifully into modern interiors. These external visual features are protected under the Designs Act, 2000 as Industrial Designs. The company has exclusive rights over these designs, ensures that no one can copy the unique physical appearance of its fans or lights.

    For taps and shower the external visual features the shape, configuration, and ornamentation are protected under the Designs Act, 2000 as Industrial Designs. As the taps have curved spouts, or black finishes, or vintage gold polish. This Design protection ensures that no competitor can copy the look of these taps or showers without permission. Consumers benefit from unique and elegant designs exclusive to that brand.

    4. THE PATENTS ACT, 1970:

    The company having BLDC technology in ceiling fans that ensure silent operation, to smart enabled fans and lights that can be operated via mobile apps or voice assistants or remote these products are often patented under the Patents Act, 1970. Some patented features include motion-sensor, fans with auto-regulation of speed based on room temperature, smart mood lighting systems that change colour based on time of day. Patents protect these functional innovations, granting exclusive rights to the company to use the invention themselves, also prevent others from copying the mechanism or feature.

    As we moved further into completing the finer details of our home, it was finally time to design the bathrooms spaces where comfort and hygiene go hand in hand. We explored products from renowned sanitaryware and looked into companies like Jaquar, Kohler, Hindware, and Grohe, and we were amazed at how much innovation goes into something as simple as a tap or showerhead. We are getting amazed by each passing day like knowing that these everyday products can carry the weight of Intellectual Property protection.

    The Modern tap and shower fittings has some features like auto-closing taps to prevent water wastage. Thermostatic mixers that balance hot and cold water perfectly. Touch-free that is sensor-based systems for hygiene. These features involve technical innovation, often protected under the Patents Act, 1970.

    This Act protects exclusive rights to the inventor and company to use the technology. Legal protection against others making, selling, or using the same invention without consent.

    5. THE GEOGRAPHICAL INDICATIONS OF GOODS ACT, 1999:

    After the structure was completed, tiles chosen, lights installed, and bathrooms made functional it was finally time to add soul to the space: the furniture, art, and cultural essence that truly turns a house into a home. For this final stage, we intentionally chose traditional, artworks and handicrafts, many of which are protected under the Geographical Indications of Goods (Registration and Protection) Act, 1999.

    Like for the main hall, we selected exquisite Mysore Traditional Paintings known for their rich colours, gold foil detailing, and mythological themes. Each painting are handmade by local artisans from Karnataka, reflected elegance and heritage. These paintings are protected by a GI tag, which confirms their origin from Mysore, Karnataka. Legally ensures that only genuine artisans from that region can label their art as “Mysore Painting”.

    And for our dining area and lounge, we chose Sankheda furniture from Gujarat beautifully built wooden chairs and tables with vibrant, hand-painted patterns and bold colours. Made using old techniques passed through generations, these pieces added traditional charm and vibrancy to our space.

    This furniture are protected under Geographical Indications, ensures the exclusive right of Sankheda artisans from the region of Gujarat to use the name.Legal protection against the mass manufacturers who are it is wrongly and falsely.

    Conclusion

    Building a home is not just about bricks it is about creativity, innovation, tradition, and that small personal touch of ours. Through every step of our journey from choosing branded tiles, to selecting GI-tagged artworks and customized blueprints we discovered how deeply Intellectual Property Rights are woven into the very fabric of our daily lives. This all about Intellectual properties in my dream house.

    This experience has not only given us a home filled with beauty and meaning but also a deeper appreciation for the laws that protect originality, craftsmanship, and innovation.

    Truly, understanding IPR has turned our dream home into a space where ideas are valued, and creators are respected.

    Author

    Nimisha Singh Kushwah, 3rd B.A.LLB, Institute of Law, Jiwaji University, Gwalior

  • GST Registration vs Udyam Registration : Key Differences and Business Requirements

    Securing appropriate Business Registrations in India is extremely important for all businesses whether big or small in order to stay compliant with laws, take advantage of benefits offered by government and to avoid future legal penalties. Two such important Business Registrations in India are GST Registration and Udyam Registration, commonly referred to as MSME (Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises) Registration.

    Duly obtaining GST Registration as well asUdyamRegistration is essential for all businesses in the country. However, the problem arises when business owners are unable to understand the difference between these two registrations. This article will help business owners distinguish between GST Registration and Udyam Registration and understand their basics in detail.

    What is GST Registration in India?

    The term GST stands for Goods & Service Tax. Registration granted to any business under the GST Law and practice regime is called GST Registration in India. GST Regime was introduced in India on 01/07/2017 which replaced multiple indirect taxes in India to come out as one comprehensive tax regime governing all Indirect Tax dealings in India. All businesses crossing the hereinunder mentioned financial threshold must obtain a GST Registration in India:

    • For businesses dealing in goods: when annual turnover crosses 40 lakh.
    • For businesses dealing in services: when annual turnover crosses 20 lakh.

    GST Law and practice mandate all businesses exceeding this financial threshold to have a GST Registration in India. GST laws and practice also mandate filing of periodical returns disclosing businesses turnovers and profits. Thus, businesses owners must be mindful of staying compliance with the GST laws and practices.

    What is Udyam Registration in India?

    Udyam Registration, previously called as Udyog Registration and also called as MSME Registration is a registration granted to Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises in India, granting them recognition as a small business. The purpose of introduction of the Udyam Registration was to help the government identify small businesses in the country and provide them with benefits such as reduced government fees, subsidiaries, easier credit facilities etc. to help such businesses sustain and grow. Businesses under the following financial threshold may be granted registration as MSMEs:

    1. Micro Enterprises: Annual Turnoverupto ₹5 crores, Investment in Plant and Machinery/Equipmentupto₹1 crore
    2. Small Enterprises:Annual Turnoverupto ₹50 crores, Investment in Plant and Machinery/Equipment upto₹10 crores
    3. Medium Enterprises:Annual Turnoverupto ₹250 crores, Investment in Plant and Machinery/Equipmentupto₹50 crores

    All MSME registered businesses must remember to file annual MSME returns to update data and avail benefits and schemes.

    Key Differences between GST Registration vs Udyog registration

    Although both are extremely important Business Registrations in India, and must be acquired by all. Still businesses owners must understand the detailed difference between  GST registration vs Udyog registration(MSME Registration).

    FEATUREGST REGISTRATIONUDYAM REGISTRATION
    Governing LawGST Law and Practicegoverned through CGST & SGST Act, 2017Micro Small and Medium Enterprise Development Act, 2006
    ObjectiveTo ensure proper tax compliance &tax collectionMSME recognition and government support
    Applicable ToTurnover-based (≥₹20–₹40 lakhs)Investment & turnover-based
    Issued ByGST Department (CBIC)Ministry of MSME
    BenefitsInput Tax Credit, legal recognitionLoans, subsidies, tender preference
    Return FilingGSTR-1, GSTR-3B, GSTR-9, etc.MSME Return annually
    RequirementMandatory for certain thresholdsOptional but highly recommended

    Which one do you need? GST Registration Vs. Udyog Registration

    Both GST Registration as well as Udyam Registration are essential for businesses registrations in India.

    A businesses needs a GST Registration if:

    • Exceeds prescribed financial turnover
    • Engages in inter-state supply
    • Has an E-commerce business

    Must obtain a GST Registration in India to stay compliant with GST Laws and practices.

    A businesses needs Udyam Registration (MSME Registration) if:

    • Comes under the financial threshold provided under the MSMED Act, 2006
    • Wants to take benefit of government schemes, subsidies, policies etc.
    • Wants recognition as an MSME to avail financial assistance

    You need both GST Registration and Udyam Registration if:

    • You are an MSME which is engaged in taxable supply of goods
    • You are a GST Registered entity which wants to take benefits of government’s schemes, subsidies and policies provided under the MSME laws
    • If you wish to obtain businesses growth, cheaper credit loans, financial assistance and funding.

    Hence, for anyone falling under the third category, we highly recommend to obtain both Businesses Registrations in India for optimum protection, growth opportunity and to stay legally compliant.

    Common Misconceptions regarding GST Registration and MSME Registration

    There are several misconceptions surrounding GST Registration and MSME Registration in India. Let’s address these misconceptions one by one:

    First and perhaps the most common misconception is that GST Registration and MSME/Udyog/Udyam Registration is the same. NO, GST Registration is for taxation, whereas Udyam Registration is for recognition of businesses’ status as a MSME.

    Second common misconception is that only large corporations need to take GST Registration. NO, any business which crosses the financial threshold of 20 lakh in case of services and 40 lakhs in case of goods can obtain a GST registration.

    Third common misconception is that Udyam Registration must be compulsory. NO, udyam registration is nothing but a recognition of a businesses’ status as a small business. It is entirely voluntary, but highly recommended.

    Conclusion:

    Both these are essential business registrations in India, however, they differ in their purpose. While GST Registration ensures tax compliance and is a mandatory registration, Udyam Registration is a mere recognition and is entirely voluntary.

    A business falling under the financial threshold of both MSME Registration and GST Registration is strongly advised to obtain both these registrations for their businesses to ensure that your business continues to stay legally compliant and at the same time has opportunities of growth and government benefits. After obtaining these business registrations in India, one must remember to timely file MSME returns and GST Returns as per the GST law and practice

    The first step however is definitely to obtain these registrations. Are you looking to obtain your GST Registration and Udyam Registration? Look no further! TMWala is here.

    Wish to read more? Click the link to know more: https://legalguruindia.com/udyam-registration-msme/

    Link to GST’s official government portal: https://www.gst.gov.in

  • Cash Flow Blunders Indian Businesses Need to Steer Clear Of

    In today’s complex business landscape, businesses need to have effective cash flow management to help the business stay afloat. Indian companies and businesses often ignore the importance of effectively managing cash inflow and cash outflow to stay ahead of the curve and keep their business functioning without day-to-day operational hassles.

    Thus, having a cash flow plan is integral for all business and should not be underestimated. This article will help businesses understand cash flow blunders Indian businesses need to steer clear of.

    Role of cash flow in financial management

    Before understanding the cash flow blunders Indian businesses need to steer clear of, we must understand the role and importance of cash flow in financial management. Cash flow has 2 components Cash Inflow and Cash Outflow.

    • Cash Inflow: Money coming in through sales, investment or loans
    • Cash Outflow: Money going out through purchases, interest payment, rent, salaries etc.

    Every Indian Company and business must understand the role of cash flow in financial management and setting up an effective cash flow plan to help in Cash Flow Management. Businesses of all sizes and industries require to take conscious efforts to help establish adequate cash flow plans.

    Common Cash Flow Blunders Indian Businesses Need to Steer Clear of

    Absence of Proper Cash Flow Plan: Indian companies and businesses often think that cash flow will take care of itself. But this is one of the biggest mistakes. Businesses need to take conscious steps to draw up a comprehensive cash flow plans periodically, Monthly or Quarterly. This is done to forecast, plan and predict future cash inflows and cash outflows to pre-emptively take corrective steps to take case of any future problems and avoid last minute surprises. It is better to be safe than sorry and this applies to drawing up a cash flow plan too.

    Ignoring timings of cash inflow and cash outflows:Simply predicting the amount of cash inflows and cash outflows is not enough. Businesses need to keep check of the timings of the cash flows to help in financial management. This becomes a bigger problem in todays time when the payment cycles get extended due to delays. In a situation where you supplier wants payment within 15 days but you will receive payment in 45 days, such a situation is an alarm for disaster. Hence, businesses need to effectively synchronise the timings of their cash inflows and cash outflows.

    Overestimating the Revenue and Underestimating the Expenses: Businesses often fail to adequately predict the amount of revenue and expenses. Businesses must remember the basic accounting Prudence Principle which dictates that businesses must account for future losses & expenses and not be over optimistic regarding the future revenue and profits. Basically one must follow a pessimistic and realistic approach in predicting their revenues and expenses to help in cash flow management. Indian companies must always maintain a cash flow buffer.

    Poor Inventory Management: Dead stock and poor inventory management could lead to the end of a businesses. Thus, businesses must correctly estimate the demand and supply of products and avoid maintaining unnecessary stock thereby leading to cash flow management. This heightens the chances of entering into a financial crunch with money being stuck in the form of dead stock especially in the FMCG sector.

    Delayed Invoicing and Collections: This is a very common yet easily avoidable problem faced by Indian companies. Businesses must aim to shorten their payment cycle as much as possible to ensure regular inflow of cash. Delays in invoicing and collections unnecessary put a burden on the business and disrupt their cash flow plan and cash flow management.

    Uncontrolled Credit Sales: A fewcredit sales here and there do not impact the businesses that much, but continuous credit sales in an uncontrollable amount can but hazardous for any businesses. Indian companies must constantly keep a  check on its credit sales and try to minimize them. Even when offering credit sales, businesses must clearly establish the grounds and limitation for payment expressly, preferably through a written agreement.

    Neglecting Tax Obligations: Businesses must not forget their tax obligations as ignoring GST, TDS and other tax obligations can lead to hefty fines and penalties. If businesses are unprepared for such tax obligations, it can disturb their entire cash flow management. This is another major cash flow blunder to avoid in Indian businesses.

    Tips to improve cash flow management in Indian companies

    1. Maintain a contingency/buffer fund to help in cases of uncertain situations or cash flow crunch.
    2. Make sure to make quarterly or monthly cash flow plans.
    3. Minimise credit sales. Even in cases of credit sales, ensure that the terms are in writing.
    4. Ensure that the payment cycle is as short as possible.
    5. Follow Prudence Principle during cash flow management.
    6. Synchronise cash inflow and cash outflows on a business.
    7. Make sure to avoid the problem of dead stock by predicting demand.
    8. Do not forgot tax obligations.

    Why role of cash flow in financial management is important more than ever?

    In a dense and competitive market like India, businesses must pay more importance to cash flow management and formulating an air-tight cash flow plan. This will protect businesses from any future unpleasant surprises and problems.

    More so, all investors, partners, businesses, suppliers look at cash flow statements during onboarding. Hence, it is now more than ever, it is super essential that cash flow blunders to avoid in indian businesses.

    Conclusion

    One of the main signs of a sustainable and thriving businesses is that a business has an effective cash flow plan and cash flow management. It is not difficult to do so, but it for sure requires conscious and consistent steps in the direction starting from preparation of periodical cash flow plans, to predicting demand, to synchronising cash inflows and cash outflows.

    A robust cash flow will help the businesses take on all its challenges, projects, onboard investors, clients, secure loans etc. So whether you are a start-up owner or a big Indian company owner, effectively managing cash flow is the answer to half of your business problems.

  • GST on Plots, Property and More

    The Goods and Services Tax (GST) 2017, has ushered in substantial changes to the Indian real estate industry today. These changes are impacting land transactions as whole, but also sale of developed plots, completed houses, and townships. Comprehending these implications is important for all developers, investors, and buyers.

    In order to comply with taxation and maximize financial planning as both buyers and sellers it is pertinent to understand the law at hand. Lets learn about the applicability of GST and GST rate on various types of property transactions and latest changes in the law.

    1. Understanding GST Applicability in Real Estate

    When it comes to real estate transactions, the GST rates really depend on the “nature of the sale.” In simpler terms, the law makes a distinction between selling land, selling properties that are still under construction, and selling properties that are ready to move into.

    1.1 GST on Sale of Plots

    The sale of undeveloped land is exempt from GST. This is in accordance to Schedule III of CGST Act, 2017, sale of land is neither supply of goods nor supply of services. So, if a person sells a plot of land without any development, it does not attract GST.

    But this exemption is only for “pure land” transaction. If any services or development activity is done on the land before sale, it may attract GST.

    1.2 GST on Developed Plots

    When land is sold with infrastructural development – roads, drainage, water pipelines, sewage systems, lighting – GST becomes applicable. Government has clarified through various advance rulings that such developments are “supply of services” and are liable to GST.

    GST Rate: GST rate on developed plots is 18% but only on development cost and not on land value itself.

    Recent Clarifications: AAR in multiple cases has held that GST is payable on the portion of the transaction attributable to land development.

    Case Law: In a ruling by Madhya Pradesh AAR (2020, it was held that any plot sold with infrastructure development is supply of service and liable to GST.

    2. GST on Fully Constructed Houses and Apartments

    The taxation of fully constructed houses depends on whether the completion certificate has been issued at the time of sale.

    2.1 Ready-to-Move-in Houses (No GST)

    If a house or apartment is sold after obtaining the completion certificate from the relevant authority, it is treated as an immovable property.

    Since GST does not apply to the sale of immovable property, no tax is levied on such transactions.

    Example: If a person buys a ready-to-move-in apartment from a builder, no GST is applicable.

    2.2 Under-Construction Properties (GST Applicable)

    The sale of an under-construction property is considered a supply of service and is taxable under GST.

    GST Rate:5% (without Input Tax Credit) for standard under-construction residential properties.

    1% for affordable housing projects.

    If a person books a flat before completion and makes payments in instalments, GST is applicable on each instalment.

    2.3 GST on Joint Development Agreements (JDAs)

    In a Joint Development Agreement or a JDA, a landowner collaborates with a developer to construct residential or commercial properties. JDAs involve different GST implications:

    • Developer’s Obligation: The developer has to pay GST on the sale of constructed units before receiving the completion certificate.
    • Landowner’s Obligation: If the landowner sells a share of developed property before receiving the completion certificate, GST is applicable.

    GST Rate: The sale of under-construction flats by the developer attracts a 5% or 1% GST, depending on the project type.

    Input Tax Credit (ITC): The GST rates on real estate projects do not allow ITC benefits, meaning developers cannot claim credit for GST paid on inputs like cement and steel.

    3. GST on Township Developments and Infrastructure Projects

    Township developments involve multiple aspects, such as residential units, commercial spaces, infrastructure development, and common amenities. The GST applicability varies for each component:

    Residential Units: Under-construction units attract GST at 5% or 1%.

    Common Infrastructure Development: The cost of roads, parks, water supply, and sewage treatment attracts 18% GST on the service portion.

    Commercial Spaces: The sale of under-construction commercial units attracts 12% GST with ITC benefits.

    4. Recent Changes in GST for Real Estate

    4.1 GST Council’s Impact

    As per the 34th meeting of the GST Council in 2019, the GST rates were revised for real estate to provide relief to homebuyers. The revised rates that are 5% and 1% were introduced without ITC to prevent tax evasion and ensure a simplified tax structure.

    4.2 GST Exemptions for Affordable Housing

    The government defines affordable housing as:

    • A unit priced up to ₹45 lakhs.
    • A unit size of up to 60 sq. meters in metropolitan cities.
    • A unit size of up to 90 sq. meters in non-metro cities.

    Such projects benefit from a lower GST rate of 1%, making housing more affordable for middle-class buyers.

    4.3 ITC Restrictions and its Impact

    Developers cannot claim Input Tax Credit (ITC) on building materials if they opt for the new tax rates. Without ITC, developers have to include GST costs in pricing, potentially increasing property rates. Some developers prefer the old 12% GST rate with ITC to reduce input costs.

    5. Practical Challenges and Compliance Issues

    5.1 Lack of Clarity in Developed Plot Taxation

    While developed plots are taxable, there is no standardized formula to separate land value from the development cost. Developers and tax authorities often dispute the taxable portion.

    5.2 Documentation and Compliance

    Buyers and sellers must ensure that invoices clearly distinguish land cost and development cost to avoid unnecessary tax liabilities.

    Thus, the developers must comply with the anti-profiteering measures to prevent price hikes in lieu of tax rate changes.

    Conclusion

    Understanding GST implications on real estate transactions is essential for both buyers and developers. While the sale of raw land and completed properties remains tax-free, transactions involving under-construction properties and developed plots attract GST.

    Key Takeaways

    • Sale of undeveloped plots is exempt from GST.
    • Developed plots attract 18% GST on the development component.
    • Under-construction properties attract 5% GST (1% for affordable housing).
    • Fully constructed houses with a completion certificate are not subject to GST.
    • Township developments have varying GST rates depending on the services included.
    • Recent changes in GST rates have removed ITC benefits for new residential projects.

    By staying informed about tax rate changes, ITC provisions, and compliance requirements, developers and homebuyers can navigate GST laws effectively and make informed real estate decisions.

    Author Details- Apoorva Lamba (2nd Year Student Madhav Mahavidyalya,Jiwaji University,Gwalior)

    References- 

    https://getswipe.in/blog/article/gst-on-sale-of-land-and-plots

    https://elplaw.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/10/Sale-of-Developed-Plot-Recent-GST-Circular-has-foxed-Developers.pdf

    You Might Also Like- 

    https://legalguruindia.com/blog-input-tax-credit-guide/

  • GST on Pharmaceuticals, Ayurveda and Medicines

    The rollout Goods and Services Tax (GST) has shaken up how the pharmaceutical industry in India handles taxes. When GST kicked off on July 1, 2017, and it took the place of several indirect taxes like VAT, Excise Duty, and CST setting up a single tax system under the government’s vision of One Nation, One Tax. GST has had a big effect on pharmaceuticals, changing their prices how they’re distributed, and what companies need to do to ensure compliance. Let’s dive into GST rate on Pharmaceuticals, ayurvedic and medicine.

    Let’s take a look at the GST rates that apply, what’s exempt, how input tax credit (ITC) works, what companies need to do to comply, and what the government policies indicate. Understanding how GST works for medicines matters to everyone from the people who make them, to the shops that sell them, and especially the folks who consume them.

    GST Rates on Medicines

    The GST framework categorizes medicines into different tax slabs. 

    1. The Essentials and Life-Saving Drugs (5% GST)

    Drugs on the National List of Essential Medicines (NLEM) have a 5% GST rate to make them affordable.

    This group covers the necessary medications. It includes medicines for diseases like cancer, diabetes, HIV, malaria, TB, heart diseases, and other such long-term health issues. You’ll find the drugs eligible for this tax rate vide Notification No. 1/2017-Central Tax (Rate), from June 28, 2017.

    2. General Medicines and Formulations (12% GST)

    Most drugs, like antibiotics, pain relievers anti-inflammatory meds, and vitamin supplements, belong to this group. Traditional Indian medical practices like Ayurveda, Unani, Siddha, and even Homeopathy medicines also attract a 12% GST rate vide Notification No. 12/2017-Central Tax (Rate) lists the GST rates for these products.

    3. Over-the-Counter (OTC) Medicines (18% GST)

    Non-prescription drugs dietary add-ons, and health-boosting items come with an 18% GST Rate. This covers energy drinks, protein powders, beauty and dermatological treatments, and lifestyle drugs like weight loss aids.

    For Example: Products like omega-3 pills, Vitamin D and herbal dietary supplements belong to this group.

    4. GST on Medical Devices and Equipment

    5% GST: Devices that save lives such as dialysis machines, pacemakers, and crucial implants.

    12% GST: Common medical gear including syringes surgical gloves, bandages, and nebulizers.

    18% GST: Advanced diagnostic and imaging tools like MRI machines, CT scanners, and X-ray machines.

    GST Exemptions on Medicines

    To keep healthcare affordable, the government has exempted certain medicines and medical supplies from GST. These exclusions include:

    1. Blood and Blood Components 

    Human blood and its components are exempt from GST due to their critical and essential nature.

    Notification No. 9/2017-Central Tax (Rate) exempts blood and related medical products.

    2. COVID-19 Medications and Vaccines

    During COVID-19 in order to support public health initiatives, vaccines and medicines for pandemic control were momentarily GST-exempt.

    Temporary tax relief on COVID-19-related medical supplies like Remdesivir, Tocilizumab, and Amphotericin B was granted as per Notification No. 05/2021-Central Tax (Rate), dated 14th June 2021.

    3. Ayurvedic and Homoeopathic Medicines-Government Schemes

    Often times tax exempted Ayurvedic and homoeopathic medications supplied to government hospitals and fall under varied welfare initiatives. This is in line with government policies where they want to promote traditional Indian medical practices.

    GST on Pharmaceutical Supply Chains

    Manufacturing, distribution, and retailing all fall under GST compliance in the pharmaceutical supply chain. Important elements are:

    1. Input Tax Credit (ITC) in Pharma

    Manufacturers and suppliers can actually get an Input Tax Credit (ITC) on things like raw materials, packaging, and transportation costs. But there are some conditions:

    • You can’t claim ITC for medicines given out as free samples or promotional goodies.
    • Also, any GST paid on expired or damaged stock? Nope, can’t get that back.

    2. Impact on Drug Prices

    Now, about drug pricing—GST has replaced a bunch of different taxes, which has made things simpler and helped level the playing field. But there’s still a worry about high GST on active pharmaceutical ingredients (APIs) because that can drive up costs for manufacturers for both international and local markets. This in turn makes the Indian Pharmaceutical Industry less competitive than Chinese Pharmaceutical Industry, where the Government actively incentivizes APIs.

    When it comes to essential medicines, the 5% GST rate really does play a role in keeping them affordable. But, you know, over-the-counter and wellness products? They face steeper taxes, which can really hit consumers.

    3. Ayurvedic and Herbal Medicines

    These types, includes Ayurveda, Siddha and Homeopathic, along with a few more traditional cures are taxed at 12% GST rate. However, if they’re marketed as cosmetics or wellness items, well, that rate bumps up to 18%.

    For instance, take Ayurvedic toothpaste—yep, that one’s got an 18% GST tag. But if you’re looking at herbal cough syrups, those are at 12%!

    Navigating Compliance and Documentation for the Pharma Industry

    1. GST Registration

    If you run a pharma business and your annual turnover is over ₹40 lakh (or ₹20 lakh in some states), then you have got to get GST registered. 

    2. GST Returns

    Alright, so here’s how returns work:

    GSTR-1: This is your monthly return where you detail all your outward supplies.

    GSTR-3B: Think of this as a summary return that covers your tax liability and claims for input tax credit.

    GSTR-9: Its annual and brings together all your transactions throughout the year.

    3. E-Invoicing Requirements

    Now, if your business is raking in more than ₹10 crore, e-invoicing is mandatory for you. This helps with real-time validation of invoices via the GST Network (GSTN). So, don’t skip this!

    4. Anti-Profiteering Measures

    Here’s something important: if there’s a reduction in GST rates, you must pass that on to your consumers. That means lowering the MRP of your medicines. It’s only fair, right?

    Recent GST Updates for the Pharmaceutical Industry

    1. GST Council’s 47th Meeting (2022)

    During this meeting, they decided to cut the GST on certain cancer drugs from 12% to just 5%. Also, orthopaedic implants and assistive devices continue to remain exempt!

    2. GST Rate Rationalization (What’s Coming Up)

    The GST Council is looking into proposals to lower GST on active pharmaceutical ingredients (APIs) and raw materials. The goal? To help reduce manufacturing costs across the board.

    Practical Implications for Businesses and Consumers

    For Pharma Businesses:

    • You really gotta classify your medicines and medical devices accurately. Otherwise, tax disputes can come knocking.
    • Proper invoicing? Super important! It keeps your ITC claims smooth and helps avoid compliance headaches.
    • Don’t forget about e-invoicing and filing your GST returns on time. Falling behind could mean penalties.

    For Consumers:

    • Good news: essential medicines have lower GST, making them more affordable.
    • Always check the GST breakdown on your bills. You want to make sure the right tax is being applied.
    • Keep an eye on MRP reductions when GST rates drop—businesses are required to pass on those savings!

    In a nutshell, GST has really streamlined the taxation process for the pharmaceutical sector. It’s done away with multiple levies and brought in a unified tax structure. While it’s made essential medicines more affordable, yet we see higher tax rates on non-essential items and wellness products. For businesses, staying compliant with GST regulations, keeping invoices in check, and planning taxes wisely are key to avoiding issues. And for consumers? Staying informed about GST rates and exemptions helps you make smarter, cost-effective healthcare choices. Just remember, knowledge is power!

    Author Details- Apoorva Lamba (2nd Year Student Madhav Mahavidyalya,Jiwaji University,Gwalior)

    References–

    https://cleartax.in/s/impact-of-gst-rate-on-pharmaceutical-industry

    https://piceapp.com/blogs/ayurvedic-medicine-gst-rate

    https://razorpay.com/learn/gst-on-medicines/

    You might also like- 

    https://legalguruindia.com/blog-medical-labels/

    https://legalguruindia.com/blog-gst-registration/